We’ve all seen them, those yellow and black end pieces of highway guardrails. And you may have wondered, as I have, why they are so blunt and what would happen if a car veered off the pavement and hit one. Now we know, sort of. They are built that way to make collisions less catastrophic than they might otherwise be. But it doesn’t always work.
In Texas last week, a jury awarded $175 million in damages in a lawsuit against Trinity Industries Inc., one maker of those guardrail “end terminals.” A competitor had sued the company under the federal “whistleblower” law, charging that Trinity had failed to disclose to the government that it had made a slight change in its “ET-Plus” guardrail terminals, a change that allegedly degraded its intended performance. Trinity was quoted in the news as planning to appeal.
The terminals are supposed to absorb the shock of a frontal collision and peel the guardrail off to the side. Footage shown on TV showed that instead, in a few cases the rail speared through the vehicles and in at least one case cut off the driver’s legs below the knees.
The Federal Highway Administration has ordered Trinity to provide new safety test data on its terminals. And in Oregon, the Department of Transportation removed the brand from its list of approved guardrail ends. ODOT says it is reviewing crash data to see if any of Trinity’s ET-brand terminals were involved.
Only 909 or 4 percent of the 22,539 guardrail terminals in Oregon are of the ET-brand made by Trinity, according to ODOT. Last week the department was awaiting further information before deciding whether to replace that type of terminal. The 909 include older ET terminals as well as the newer ET-Plus type involved in the Texas verdict.
For this story I went looking for guardrail terminals Sunday and found four on Highway 99E about a couple of miles south of Tangent. I could not tell the brand or make, but they looked similar to the photo on Trinity’s website. Regardless of the make, those end pieces looked nothing if not stout. It was hard for me to imagine how they might give way to absorb the energy of a collision, especially if the driver careless or unlucky enough to hit one drove a small passenger car. (hh)