HASSO HERING

A perspective from Oregon’s mid-Willamette Valley

Phone use banned and what else?

Written September 14th, 2017 by Hasso Hering

Photographing your speedometer at 63 mph apparently will remain legal as long as it’s not done with a “mobile electronic device.”

ODOT has put out a one-page “distracted driving fact sheet.” Unfortunately it does not clarify what was left unclear by the lengthy process in the 2017 legislature of drafting and amending and finally passing House Bill 2597.

The law expands the existing cell phone ban while driving, and it calls for tougher penalties for violations. The ODOT fact sheet reminds us that it takes effect in a couple of weeks, on Oct. 1.

What’s unclear, you ask? Well, ODOT says that under the law “it is illegal to drive while holding or using an electronic device (e.g. cell phone, tablet, GPS, laptop).” That’s fine, and it captures the intent of the chief sponsor, Rep. Andy Olson, R-Albany, and the other supporters of the bill. But it’s not the only thing that the bill bans, and nobody can say what all it does ban.

In response to an appeals court ruling that held the existing ban applied only to talking and texting, not to other uses of cell phones like checking email, it would have been a simple matter to revise the law to include “any use of a cell phone for which the phone is designed.”

Instead, the law now says that “using a mobile electronic device includes BUT IS NOT LIMITED to … text messaging, voice communication, entertainment, navigation, accessing the Internet or producing electronic mail.” So what else is banned? The law doesn’t say.

In the same way, it says that a “mobile electronic device includes BUT IS NOT LIMITED TO a device capable” of texting, talking, entertainment, producing email and cruising the Internet. So, if the term is not limited to those things, what else does it include? It could include anything you might use in a car.

The law does not apply to using hands-free or built-in devices, and it allows “a single touch or swipe to activate or deactivate the device.” So presumably you are still allowed to turn on the radio manually. But what about changing stations, which sometimes requires more than “a single touch.”

It’s pretty clear that under this new law taking cell phone pictures from my truck will no longer be legal. So when I need a shot of traffic to illustrate a story, I’ll go back to the camera I used before. Whether that is covered by the phrase “not limited to,” I’m not sure. (hh)

 



9 responses to “Phone use banned and what else?”

  1. David Ballard says:

    Rep. Andy Olson has always received my vote, but with his sponsorship and support of this “mommy state” legislation, that support is now withdrawn. Should the government legislate the minutiae of our lives? If so, what about the woman I see behind the wheel juggling her coffee and putting on her makeup during the early morning commute to work?

    There is no end to that which may be legislated.

  2. Tony White says:

    What about mobile amateur radio communication, which has been used for decades by hams for emergency and disaster coordination with law enforcement?

  3. Nancy Sturm says:

    Suspecting that you are nothing if not compliant, I envision you steering with your elbows while photographing Greater Albany with a 35 mm manual camera, no electronics of course.

  4. Steven Mills says:

    It seems that common sense isn’t so common anymore. Remember that the purpose of the law is to focus on driving and putting away distractions. Any device that takes hands off the wheel and eyes off the road are subject to the law.

  5. MJ Stalnaker says:

    When will eating your fast food order come up on the radar. It is equally distracting as talking on your cell phone. More so when the ketchup drips down the front of your shirt.

  6. Rich Kellum says:

    The only part of this law that bothers me is that some folks are immune to it. Driving distracted is either a problem or it isn’t. I think it is, so NO ONE should be immune to the consequences. Or do away with it. But if you do away with it, don’t complain about the people running over people while texting.

 

 
Cycle around town!
Copyright 2019. All Rights Reserved. Hasso Hering.
Website Serviced by Santiam Communications
Do NOT follow this link or you will be banned from the site!